Interesting piece here about Microsoft’s Project Sopris. There’s also an interesting paper giving background to the approach. It’s become a thing when people talk about IoT to slam its security but, in the end, this is just another engineering problem to solve. If IoT class processors were available with built-in and easy to use (without being a security expert) security features, I’d like to think that people would use them and this barrier to implementation would be removed permanently.
Working with the Bosch XDK reminded me that temperature sensing seems like such an obvious concept but it is actually very tough to do and get correct results. The prototype above was something I tried to do in a startup a few years ago, back when this kind of thing was all the rage. It combined motion sensing, the usual environmental sensors including air quality and could have a webcam attached if you wanted video coverage of the space also.
In this photo of the interior you can see my attempt at getting reasonable results from the temperature sensor by keeping the power and ground planes away from the sensor – the small black chip on the right of the photo. Trouble is, the pcb’s FR-4 still conducts heat, as do the remaining copper traces to the chip. Various other attempts followed included cutting a slot through the FR-4 and isolating the air above the rest of the circuit board from the sensor. This is an example:And this is a thermistor design (with some additional wireless hardware):
In the end, the only solution was to use a thermistor attached by wires that could be kept some distance from the main circuitry. Or, just having all the very low power sensors completely removed from the processor.
The Raspberry Pi Sense HAT suffers from this problem as it is right above the Pi’s processor, as does the Bosch XDK itself. Actually I am not aware of any other really good solution apart from the one where a cable is used to separate the sensor board completely from the processor controlling it (which might work for the Sense HAT although I have not tried that.
Turned out to be really easy to drive Apache NiFi from the Bosch XDK sensor node via MQTT. The XDK actually has an MQTT example project that does pretty much everything for you – it’s the MQTT Paho demo on this page. I am using it with the mosquitto broker on Ubuntu.
The screen capture shows the output of a simple display application that subscribes to the MQTT topic and graphs the sensor values. This is actually a version of sensorview in the rtndf GitHub repo. It doesn’t display the gyro or magnetometer data from the XDK but it displays the rest of the data.
On the Apache NiFi side of things, I am using the ConsumeMQTT processor. This is an example of a data record recovered from the provenance data.
One day, if I am feeling really keen, I could port the old RTIMULib2 software onto the XDK and fill out the sensorpose field in the message with something other than zeroes.
Just got a Bosch XDK sensor to try out – seems like it could be the basis of a very functional environmental sensor. It has a bunch of hardware sensors in a nice little package that includes a battery, WiFi and Bluetooth connectivity and can be wall mounted. You can certainly do the same thing with a Raspberry Pi but it is not so convenient, especially when you need battery power.
Seems that intel has given up on the IoT space to large extent by cancelling the Edison amongst other things. They had a few things going for them, especially when paired with a battery card.
The combo above is certainly more compact than a Raspberry Pi equivalent but somehow it was always a pain to work with. Maybe just a bit too embedded. Mine got consigned to the “technology I no longer have time or space for” bin in the garage quite a long time ago whereas Raspberry Pis continue to multiply.
The earlier Smart space post got me thinking about other related projects and I came across these old screen captures from the AwareSpace project. This was a much more serious attempt to make use of ubiquitous sensor data. It worked fine, giving easy access to real time and historic data from sensors. There was even web access to the system. Like many projects, it was never really finished and needed a lot more work to do everything that I wanted. One day…
The project starting collecting dust when I couldn’t really think of good ways of using the data, beyond triggering an alarm under some conditions or something. However, it’s often interesting just to see what’s going on around the place so I have revived the sensors (a good use for old first generation Pis). The screen capture shows a simple but actually quite effective way of using the data that’s being generated, providing a display that’s adjacent to the camera feed from a webcam on the same Pi. Between the two streams, you can get good confidence on what’s happening in the smart space.
One day, I’d like to get the HoloLens integrated with this so that I can see the data when I am in the smart space. That would be even more fun.